Buy My Book Here

Fox News Ticker

Please check out my new books, "Prosecutors Gone Wild: The Inside Story of the Trial of Chuck Panici, John Gliottoni, and Louise Marshall" and also, "The Definitive Dossier of PTSD in Whistleblowers"

Wednesday, July 15, 2009

Another Strawman Argument from President Obama

President Obama has again employed a straw man argument in trying to sell the newly minted health care reform package.

But taking a stern tone, Obama accused his health care critics of "defending the status quo." He said he wants the House and Senate to pass out bills before the August recess, so that they can settle on one unified bill that he can sign shortly after lawmakers return from break.

"This is a problem that we can no longer defer," Obama said, flanked by nurses. "Deferring reform is nothing more than defending the status quo -- and those who would oppose our efforts should take a hard look at just what it is that they're defending."

He described the current system as one in which costs are skyrocketing as thousands lose coverage, saying the status quo is "not an option" for Americans anymore.


President Obama is attempting to use the same argumentative technique he has used throughout the debate on most domestic policy. He has made a habit of saying that anyone that disagrees with his vision wants to do NOTHING.

That's the rhetorical trick he tried to do when the stimulus debate was in full swing. I remember President Obama, in his first televised news conference, proclaiming that he disagreed with those that said that we should do nothing.

I have already debunked the idea that Republican opponents of President Obama have no ideas. The Republicans are tied to several health care reform plans: including ones by John Shadegg and another by Robert Bennett. No one is saying that the status quo is all right. The question is whether or not a massive government take over of health care is the right idea.

The president appears to not want to have that debate. As such, he creates a strawman argument in which the only one with an idea is him. That's simply not the case. If "health care reform" was his agenda, there would be dozens of plans on the table. Instead, the president insists on the government option, mandates, and increasing taxes to pay for it. The Republicans aren't merely saying no and offering nothing. They have offered their competing options. The president has ignored them entirely, and now he's pretending they don't even exist.

2 comments:

Anonymous said...

I can't think of any politicians off the top of my head, but Rush definitely has made it perfectly clear he does not believe there is a health care crisis.

Neither does Larry Elder.

mike volpe said...

Both of those folks are commentators. I am sure there are some that don't want to do anything, but the Republicans have alternatives. Obama is making the argument that it's his plan or nothing, and that's not true.