Buy My Book Here

Fox News Ticker

Please check out my new books, "Bullied to Death: Chris Mackney's Kafkaesque Divorce and Sandra Grazzini-Rucki and the World's Last Custody Trial"

Showing posts with label sociopath. Show all posts
Showing posts with label sociopath. Show all posts

Wednesday, September 16, 2009

Propping a Psychopath: The Cone of Silence

UPDATE: Please also check out my new book, The Definitive Dossier on PTSD in Whistleblowers, for only $3.99, in which I dedicate chapter four entirely to the exploits of Dr. Anna Chacko. 

Introduction: This is my fourth, and nowhere near last, edition in my series of exposes of Dr. Anna Chacko. The circumstances that surround this story are long and quite complicated. As such, I encourage all new readers to read my three previous pieces, here, here, and here. That said, I will try and summarize the story thus far as best I can so that readers can follow along.

Dr. Anna Chacko is currently the head of radiology at the Pittsburgh VA Hospital. She has been there since October 2008. She is also, in my estimation, a Psychopath. Almost immediately following her arrival there, folks at the VA began complaining about her behavior. She bullied people, she lied about people, and she created an environment of terror. As such in March of this year, an investigative board was formed. The recommendation of that board was to have Dr. Chacko removed as director of radiology and this decision came in April. Then, Dr. Chacko challenged the results, hired an attorney, and began reaching out to politicians. She reached out to Congressman Brad Miller of North Carolina. He reached out to General Eric Shinseki, the head of the entire VA, and eventually word came down from his office to keep Dr. Chacko in her position. She continues there to this day and sources tell me that the situation has only gotten worse since she was put back in her position.

Since writing the first piece, folks from Seattle, to Boston, to Pittsburgh, and everywhere in between have reached out to me. They have filled in a picture of Dr. Chacko that goes back nearly two decades. This picture is of an individual that terrorizes, stabs people, black mails, and leaves people in her path with post traumatic stress disorder for having to deal with her. I have heard stories of terror and criminality that goes back to the early 1990's. It spans many different states and hospitals. Yet, she continues to operate and in fact, she continues to thrive. Dr. Chacko is worth reportedly in excess of $10 million. She maintains 10 thousand plus residence in Butte, Mt., and as I mentioned, she currently heads up the radiology department at the Pittsburgh VA. Her salary there is about $300,000 yearly.

As I tracked Dr. Chacko from Texas, to Boston, to Butte, Mt. and finally to Pittsburgh, there was one thing that I couldn't understand. This woman is a real in the flesh Psychopath. Everywhere she goes it's the same thing. She comes in. She targets those that won't go along with her. She lies about them. She terrorizes them, until they quit or get fired. She turns the workplace into a state of horror and chaos. It's the same thing at every place. Yet, she continues to find new work. So, how does it happen? I will examine that in this piece. With that, the introduction is over.

...

First, let me welcome my new fans. They are the employees of Lahey Clinic in Boston, Ma. You know who you are and I know when you visit. I have a trusty stat counter that is a plethora of information including the Internet service provider of my visitors. When someone from Lahey Clinic visits, that's clearly marked. These visitors have come in the hundreds nearly each and everyday to read each of the three stories I have written about Dr. Chacko so far. With all sincerity, I thank you for visiting and I hope you come back often.

You folks have a unique interest in these stories. That's because from 2001-2006, Dr. Anna Chacko was the head of radiology at Lahey Clinic. There are still many folks there that worked at Lahey when she was there. Boy, what stories you could probably tell. Unfortunately, you aren't telling them to me. That's not because there aren't any stories to tell. Dr. Chacko terrorized those that didn't go along with her. She bought millions of dollars worth radiology equipment, almost exclusively from GE, She was alleged to have taken kickbacks for all the equipment purchases, sharing patient records, among a slew of offenses. When she was finally removed, she was forcibly removed by security. On her way out, she screamed, "kiss my big, Indian ass".

Yet, there is nothing but silence from Lahey. In fact, I can confirm that Lahey is proactively trying to silence people with knowledge of the situation. (more on that in a bit) Why is Lahey protecting Dr. Chacko? Below is a copy of an internal email sent on February 14th, 2007 from the higher ups at Lahey to the staff regarding Dr. Chacko.






Reference is made to the resignation of Dr. Anna Chacko from Lahey's Department of Radiology in April of 2006. Further to the discussions that I have had with a number of you, and in accordance with the requirements of an agreement that Lahey reached with Dr. Chacko in connection with her resignation from the Clinic, I write to remind you that you are not to make any disparaging comments about her.

Thank you.


It doesn't take too much intuition to figure out what's going on here. After Dr. Chacko left, there was a lawsuit and as part of the lawsuit both sides were to keep quiet. Now, I understand why Lahey did this. Dr. Chacko spent about six years at Lahey. By the end, people were at their wits end. They were exhausted. I'm certain that it was Dr. Chacko that came back looking to sue. That's her Modus Operandi. When she did, the powers that be at Lahey likely had enough and they most certainly paid her off and agreed to keep silent because they knew that if they agreed to this, she would be out of their professional lives forever.

Of course, such thoughts are short sighted. The powers that be knew exactly what they were dealing with. No one I have spoken with has challenged my assertion that Dr. Chacko is a Psychopath. I doubt the higher ups at Lahey didn't know this when they agreed to this settlement. Once they did, they unleashed her on the rest of the health care industry.

Once she was unleashed, Dr. Chacko made her way through the rest of the country and destroyed everything in her path. She wound up as head of radiology at St. James Hospital in Butte, Mt. She was there for fourteen months and yet she is party to no less than three different lawsuits. There are folks at that hospital that used to be best friends for years and are now enemies because Dr. Chacko forced each to choose sides. The hospital is on the brink of bankruptcy. The radiology department is in total chaos, and the CEO that hired her, James Kiser, has lost his job. St. James Hospital could have been warned but the agreement is clear. No one at Lahey could speak in a "disparaging" way against Dr. Chacko. So, if they called her former employer, they were in no position to tell the truth.

At the Pittsburgh VA, Dr. Chacko has engaged in threatening behavior. She singles out people she doesn't like and spreads lies within the department about them. She doesn't allow anyone in the radiology department to speak to anyone else about anything that isn't work related. She threatens legal resident aliens with calling immigration if they cross her. She refuses to do clinical work. The hospital is so afraid of her that the H.R. department refuses to investigate the continued complaints that staff has been making about her. The Pittsburgh VA, much like St. James, was totally unprepared for her terror. In part, that's because her former employers, Lahey Clinic included, weren't in a position to speak freely about her. In an effort to wash their hands of her, they agreed to remain silent. In doing so, they allowed her to unleash herself on other unsuspecting medical establishments.

Lahey is so concerned that Dr. Chacko is going to sue them that the hospital continues to actively silence anyone in a position to speak about Dr. Chacko and her exploits. I was tipped to a doctor that currently works near me at a hospital in Aurora, Illinois. I was told that on one occasion, Dr. Chacko, in front of a staff meeting of dozens of doctors, lit into this doctor. Dr. Chacko screamed at her calling her lazy, careless, stupid, etc. She did this while the rest of the staff sat in shock and horror. I reached out to the victim of this barrage. She confirmed the story and even said, "I remember it like it was yesterday." We spoke briefly however I called her at work. So, we agreed to speak later after she got off work. I never spoke to her again. According to two sources, she then reached out to Lahey Clinic and was told that she shouldn't speak with me. One source tells me that she called her former boss, Dr. Carl R. Larsen, and asked if she should speak with me. He advised her not to.

By doing so, Lahey continued to make sure that the truth doesn't get out. Their only agenda is to protect the agreement they made with Dr. Chacko more than two years ago. As such, the hospital won't be sued and there won't be any unnecessary attention paid to it. Meanwhile, because the truth doesn't get out, Dr. Chacko is allowed to operate freely. If everyone at Lahey Clinic spoke freely and truthfully about their recollections of Dr. Chacko, she would immediately be suspended from any medical duties. That's because while she was there she systematically violated numerous medically ethical protocols. The definition of a "disruptive physician", just for instance, is so loose that it would only take a handful of stories to have any number of medical boards label her as a "disruptive physician". That would only be the beginning of the potential charges.

I can say without a doubt that if everyone from Lahey that has been reading my articles would reach out to me to tell what they know that the next day there would be enough evidence to remove her immediately from her position at the Pittsburgh VA. In fact, there would be enough evidence for a serious Congressional investigation that is so long overdue. Yet, that isn't happening. It isn't happening because the powers that be at Lahey decided to take the easy way out. Instead of confronting her and making sure that she never did to anyone else what she did to their hospital, they paid her off and silenced themselves. By doing so, they also made sure that she could unleash herself on the rest of the medical community and they would be totally unaware of what they are dealing with. They washed their hands of her but also made sure that she could do to others what she had done to them for six long years. That's exactly what she's done. The folks at Lahey no longer have to deal with the nightmare of Dr. Chacko. Unfortunately, the folks currently working at the Pittsburgh VA aren't quite as lucky as those at the Lahey Clinic. Their nightmare is still unfolding. Had they been warned they wouldn't have a nightmare.

Epilogue:

Here's the definitive dossier of Dr. Chacko.


Sunday, September 6, 2009

A Psychopath at the Pittsburgh VA

UPDATE: Please also check out my new book, The Definitive Dossier on PTSD in Whistleblowers, for only $3.99, in which I dedicate chapter four entirely to the exploits of Dr. Anna Chacko. 

Dr. Anna Chacko
Reckless disregard for the safety of self or others

Impulse control problems

Irresponsibility

Inability to tolerate boredom

Pathological narcissism
Shallow affect
Deceitful/manipulative

Aggressive or violent tendencies, repeated physical fights or assaults on others

Lack of empathy
Lack of remorse, indifferent to or rationalizes having hurt or mistreated others

A sense of extreme entitlement
Lack of or diminished levels of anxiety/nervousness and other emotions

Promiscuous sexual behavior, sexually deviant lifestyle

Lack of personal insight

Failure to follow any life plan

Abuse of drugs including alcohol

Disregard for conventional moral right and wrong

Glibness/superficial charm

Grandiose sense of self-worth


Cunning/manipulative

Lack of remorse or guilt

Emotionally shallow

Callous/lack of empathy

Failure to accept responsibility for own actions

Criminal versatility


That's a fairly size able list of Psychopathic behavioral traits. A few days ago, I did a story that centered around a doctor named Dr. Anna Chacko. Dr. Chacko is currently the head of radiology in the VA hospital in Pittsburgh. I also believe beyond a shadow of a doubt that she's a Psychopath. Dr. Chacko has engaged in a reign of terror that has taken her all over Texas, Colorado, San Francisco, Boston, Butte, Montana, Hawaii, and most recently Pittsburgh. What I'd like to do is list off some examples of the characteristics from some of the most intense stories I've heard about her so far. I've had about ten conversations with folks from Butte, Mt., Boston, Ma., Pittsburgh, Pa., and Seattle Wa. This is the most shocking stories and the body of work will leave the reader with no doubts. Dr. Anna Chacko is a Psychopath and she's currently working at the Pittsburgh VA Hospital. I'd like to start with the bottom and work my way up.


1)Criminal versatility


There are several great stories of Dr. Chacko's criminal versatility. Let's start with her relationship to Dr. Bob Shah. This is a doctor that seems to follow her almost everywhere she goes. (Dr. Chacko on page 1 and both are on page 8 Lab Project) I can confirm that he now works with her at the Pittsburgh VA, prior to that at St. James Hospital, at the Lahey Clinic (in the benefactors section pages 5 and 6), and at the Boston University Medical Center. I also know that they were stationed together at Brooke Army Medical Center in San Antonio, Texas as military M.D.'s. Sometime in the early 1990's. Dr. Shah made an error in reading an X ray. As a result, he missed some sort of a treatable abnormality. Because it wasn't caught, the patient died. This would be a civil lawsuit in the regular medical world. In the military however, there's no such thing as a civil suit. It's all criminal. He would have been facing serious hard time. Instead, Dr. Chacko made sure the x ray got lost and he got off. Now, however, he follows her around the country wherever she needs him. She'll force him to move his family without notice. He has to do it because she uses that as blackmail against him and has since the incident.
For about 6 years she worked at the Lahey Clinic in Burlington, Massachusetts, a suburb of Boston. She worked there for an unusually long while. Often Dr. Chacko doesn't make it for more than a year and a half. She stayed around longer because initially she turned the radiology department around. She upgraded their technology and streamlined their operation. That was what the folks at Lahey call the "honeymoon period". Soon after, she turned but by then she had long ingratiated herself there.
Now, normally it's easier for Dr. Chacko to manipulate the system in a VA where she has more connections. Keep in mind she's a twenty year veteran. So, it's often more difficult for her to manipulate the system in a private hospital. This is important to know because Dr. Chacko always attempts to get kickbacks through her ability to facilitate equipment purchases. She gets into bed with equipment makers like Fuji and GE. She directs their business to the hospital she's working at and they give her a kickback. This is what she would have liked to do at Lahey and sometimes she did. (there's a great story on that which I'll tell later)
So, Dr. Chacko figured out how to make money from a VA regardless. There was VA in the area. It's called the West Roxbury VA Hospital. At this hospital, they had unusually good radiologists. The lead of the department was a gentleman named Dr. Elon Gale. At some point, Dr. Chacko befriended Dr. Shukri Khori, the head surgeon at the West Roxbury VA Clinic. Dr. Chacko got Dr. Khori to go to the Inspector General of the hospital and complain that Dr. Gale's contract was negotiated improperly. This was the first of several complaints that Dr. Khori filed against the department. While the charges were eventually dismissed. Dr. Gale experienced such a hostile work environment that he left the clinic and he took most of the good radiologists with him.
With the radiology department in tatters, Dr. Chacko swoops in and offers for Lahey to contract out staff, equipment, and supplies to the VA Hospital. More than that, she used many of her connections in the VA to secure it. Then, once she swooped in, she was then able to secure it so she made all the decisions for the department. They buying and kickbacks began. Now, I'd say that's extremely criminally versatile.
2)Emotionally shallow.
She's married and has been for a bit. That said, her husband is a house husband. She likes it that way. Then, she has total control over him. It's said that when she gets home, she purposely makes a mess of her clothes. Then, she sits back on the couch while her husband gets on his knees to pick up all the clothes and put them back in the right place. She expects him to wait on her hands and knees. That's what she gets.
3)Cunning and manipulative.
Most of the time, Dr. Chacko would simply lie on the form when getting a new job when it asked whether she had been fired before. Of course, most of the time she was travelling from state to state. For whatever reason, interstate didn't catch it unless you looked closely. Most new companies didn't or Dr. Chacko arranged the job. In this case, she needed to move quickly from Lahey to BU. She she had to have a new job secured before she was fired or that would come up since it was within the same state. It got so out of control at Lahey Clinic that management sent in a spy to be her new "radiology manager". Once they got enough evidence, they were ready to remove her. She knew it was only a matter of time till they physically removed her. She began to furiously fill out and fax everything to BU. She barely made it also. She literally sent them out on a Friday and Monday security was called in to remove her. She screamed "kiss my big Indian ass" the whole time the guards were carrying her out.
4)Pathological liar
First, Dr. Chacko, more often than not, gets kicked out of places rather than quits. If you are fired at a hospital, you are supposed to disclose that to the next hospital. She hasn't and that's an example of her pathological lying. In court documents in her case against Kristi George (Montana Second Judicial District Court Silver Bow County Cause No DV 07-298), Ms. George accused Dr. Chacko of smearing her behind her back. Kristi George was the radiology manager of St. James hospital. Dr. Chacko would use her position in power to buy all sorts of equipment and services all while getting a kick back from the company. She needed a dirty radiology manager to pull this off since the radiology manager is the one that makes those orders. John Elliott is one such dirty radiology manager and he often follows her around the country. So, it was imperatively that Dr. Chacko get rid of Ms. George. As such, Dr. Chacko engaged in a systematic campaign of talking bad about Ms. George. Dr. Chacko would criticize and complain about Ms. George. In fact, the court documents even conclude that Dr. Chacko was doing this with the intent of getting Ms. George to leave. Dr. Chacko is also accused of altering medical reports. She's en accused of allowing her husband access to patient records. This is all merely during her fourteen months at St. James Hospital in Butte, Mt. St. James is a co defendant for allowing Dr. Chacko to reign free. In fact, the whole Sisters of Charity of Leavenworth Health Systems, Inc. which the system that St. James is a part of, is a co defendant, along with 5 John Doe defendants. In cour documents, it's stipulated that "Dr. Chacko made statements at the time that she knew were untrue." There's of course no better source than court transcripts. In fact, this is her M.O., it's to make up false hoods against people she doesn't like in order to try and get them to leave.
5)Grandiose self worth.
A great example of this is how Dr. Chacko force all her colleagues to call her Colonel. Even forcing her husband to pick up after her is a sign of that.
6) Promiscuous behavior
This one is hard to read however Dr. Chacko is prone to speaking inappropriately about a plethora of sexual escapades in her past. In one story, she got into a limo wearing NOTHING but a fur coat. From there, Dr. Chacko described in graphic detail a night of wild sex. Finally, Dr. Chacko was kicked out of the military for sexual misconduct. It was later white washed by her political fixer, Lt. General James Peake, the former head of the entire VA system. Then, there's her book, Out of India. It's full of raunchy stories about her in her youth in all sorts of sexual encounters.
This almost goes without saying. She has hurt many, many people, from Boston, Burlington, Butte, Mt., Colorado, all over Texas, San Francisco and in Hawaii. She's done all this to benefit herself. No matter how wealthy she gets she demands to have more. She expects to control everyone she comes into contact with. She has a group of cronies that include such names as Dr. Bob Shah, John Elliott, and Scott Steinfeldt. They follow her around the country whenever they're told to do so by Dr. Chacko. Dr. Shah, for instance, has been with her at the Lahey Clinic, BU Medical Center, St. James, and now at the Pittsburgh VA. The examples of her narcissism are everywhere and I could literally go on forever.
8) Irresponsibility
Of course, in a sense, her whole entire life is irresponsible. Specifically, before she even arrived in Butte, Montana, she accused a doctor there of threatening her harm and implying he would shoot her, even though she knew they'd never had more than a fifteen second phone call.
9)Impulse control problems.
Dr. Chacko often got a kickback from the machine maker. In one case, Dr. Chacko secured a deal with a machine maker just as it was going under. In between the time it was secured and the equipment was delivered, her contact at the company had lost their job. So, Dr. Chacko wasn't going to be able to get the kickback. So, while it was being delivered she demanded the salesperson take it back. As a result, the sales person could be heard yelling, "you certainly didn't have a problem with our machines when we were sending you to India".
I can also confirm that Dr. Chacko, while in Butte, Mt., was involved in lawsuits with at least two former colleagues, the aforementioned Ms. George and Dr. Jesse Cole. Dr. Chacko arrived in Butte, Mt. in June of 2007 and was gone by the next summer.
10)Reckless disregard for the safety of others.
In fact, that's often the conclusion of the court in her case against Ms. George. For instance, "Chacko knew or should have known that her actions would cause George serious emotional distress" was the conclusion at one point. She had no qualms about blowing up the radiology department at the VA in Boston in order to generate more business for herself.
Obviously, I could go on and on. Hopefully, no one doubts that this woman is a real life Psychopath. That's the context for the situation she's in now. Currently, she works at the Pittsburgh VA. She's the head of radiology. She's been there since October of last year. About three years ago, there was an investigation into a strand of legionella that went missing at this same Pittsburgh VA. Two administrators, Dr. Rajiv Jain and Dr. Mona Melham, were deeply involved in that scandal. These are two of the administrators that Dr. Chacko answers to, though that's currently in name only. So, Dr. Chacko has come in, totally terrorized everyone, and when there were complaints, she made it seem as though it was a conspiracy put in motion by Drs. Jain and Melham. The hospital tried to get rid of her both this past March and May but Dr. Chacko was able to call in serious political juice and stop it. I know this because I have incontrovertible evidence that Congressman Brad Miller told the current head of the V.A. General Eric Shinseki as much back in May of this year. Congressman Miller lead the investigation in 2006 that fingered both Dr.'s Jain and Melham. Soon after this correspondence, word came down from the General's office to the Pittsburgh VA that Dr. Chacko would stay on board. So far, neither Congressman Miller nor General Shinseki have responded to either of these stories.
This is a hospital with a lot of foreigners that aren't yet U.S. citizens. She has all the connections she needs from her two decades in the military and her connection to General James Peake. In fact, I am nearly certain that she has her current job because of Peake. I can confirm that she loves to put a photo of General Peake in her office. That's what she did while working at Lahey and, at the Pittsburgh VA, there's a photo of Peake in her office.
She is trying to run the entire department. She wants to either have a lackey in place or intimidate staff so that she does as she pleases. That way no one will get in the way of her as she totally transforms the department and gets a kick back from all of the transformation. She's already been pushing some new GE machine even though the current one works just fine. She's being resisted by most of her staff because it works fine. She will probably need to get rid of most of them if she's to make any new purchases. She clearly has the will, the psychopathy, and the juice to do it also. She's willing to exploit any and all weaknesses in this hospital to get her way. Her agenda as always is to figure out how to make as much money as possible through any shady deal necessary. Because she has an extraordinary amount of juice at the VA system, she is capable of nearly anything, and that's what she'll do to achieve her goals.
As you can see, I have presented a dynamic in which there is plenty to exploit. This is the nightmare facing the Pittsburgh VA unless she is stopped. At least three people, and almost certainly many more, are directly responsible for this. First, it's Congressman Brad Miller. I encourage you to call his office at 202-225-3032 and email has press person Luann Canipe at luann.canipe@mail.house.gov. Please ask politely why Congressman Miller insists on protecting this Psychopath. Ask him how much he knew about Dr. Chacko before he reached to General Shinseki on her behalf. In fact, his colleagues on the House Health and Science Investigative sub committe should know about what Congressman Miller has done.
You should also email the head of the VA, General Eric Shinseki at eric.shinseki@va.gov. He's ultimately responsible for keepin her in her job. Ask him if he knew about her entire history before he micromanaged in the business of the Pittsburgh VA and forced them to keep her on.
Also, you should contact Matt Dinkel, matt.dinkel@mail.house.gov, the main press person for Congressman Mike Doyle. You can also call Doyle's D.C. office at 202-225-3084. This hospital is in his district and he should know exactly what the threat to his constituents is.
Epilogue:

Friday, December 19, 2008

The Sociopathic Politician

The other evening over at a friend's house, he had that day's Wall Street Journal. On the front page was yet another story about Rod Blagojevich. In our discussion of Blagojevich, I referred to him as a textbook case of a Sociopath...

defined by the American Psychiatric Association's Diagnostic and Statistical Manual: "The essential feature for the diagnosis is a pervasive pattern of disregard for, and violation of, the rights of others that begins in childhood or early adolescence and continues into adulthood."[1] Deceit and manipulation are considered essential features of the disorder. Therefore, it is essential in making the diagnosis to collect material from sources other than the individual being diagnosed.


In a matter of fact tone, my friend said that he felt all politicians were Sociopaths. While this maybe an overstatement, in many ways politics breeds Sociopaths. First, a politician's job is ultimately to get re elected. The art of getting re elected is ultimately as selfish a process as they get. You aren't ever necessarily doing what's right but rather what you think the most people will find suitable, acceptable, or worthy of getting their vote next time. Politicians make decisions almost always based on the politics of a situation not the policy. The politics of any situation is always based on self interest not the interest of the public at large. Such a mindset breeds the sort of selfishness that is inherent in Sociopaths.

Second, politics is in essence all about the accumulation of power. Power is is a zero sum activity. As such, the process of accumulating power involves taking power away from someone else: opponents, citizens, etc. The process of accumulating power is also inherently selfish in a way that breeds Sociopaths. Furthermore, most Sociopaths are not only charming but extremely manipulative and both of those are traits most successful politicians.

The Sociopathic politician with which I am most familiar with is an individual out of Georgia by the name of Vernon Jones. Jones is suspected in six rapes since the mid 1980's. The last of which was described to my by a source I consider very reliable in graphic detail involving a three some gone wrong. This happened Christmas a few years back.

Jones, for many years, was CEO of DeKalb County in Georgia. He used this position to get inside information on many land deals that became profitable for himself. In his role as CEO of DeKalb County, he was also responsible for choosing the members of the board of Grady Hospital. He made Robert Brown head of the board for several years. Brown then used Grady on multiple occasions as piggy bank directing business from Grady to the architecture firm he owned. Meanwhile, Grady has gone through multiple bouts of financial dire straits while members of the board, like Brown, have seen enormous wealth for themselves.

Jones also oversaw one of the most corrupt police departments in the country, the Dekalb County Police Department. In 2001, while he was CEO of DeKalb County, Sheriff Elect Derwin Brown was murdered by the outgoing Sheriff Syd Dorsey. This was the culmination of decades of corruption at the DeKalb County Police Department including nearly a decade on his watch. Jones proceeded to install Thomas Brown (no relation), one of his cronies, to replace the deceased Derwin Brown. Thomas Brown proceeded to make nothing more than cosmetic changes to the department. The jail nearly built the penthouse of prisons for Dorsey until that was discovered and broken by an investigative journalist. In 2006, his opponent for CEO of DeKalb County, Ron Marshall, was followed, had unwarranted background checks done, and eventually Marshall mysteriously wound up in the Terror Watch List.

Finally, I believe that Jones is involved in the cover up of the apparent suicide of Charles Hicks using another one of his cronies, Donald Frank, to cover up a homicide. Frank wound up serving as Jones' Homeland Security Director for DeKalb County. He did all of this while he was supposed to be running the County of DeKalb.

The behavior of Blagojevich can also be classified as textbook Sociopathic. Nearly everything he has done while in office has been for self benefit at the expense of the public. All the corruption, bribery, and quid pro quos, have been done in order to gain personal wealth, power, and influence, and all at the expense of the public he has served.

For real horror stories of what terror a Sociopathic politician can breed, we need to look at any despot around the world. Sociopaths like Hitler, Stalin, and Hussein all brought terror to their own people and their neighbors for decades. All of these folks were so consumed by power that anyone that stood in their way was eliminated. Entire populations were subverted, eliminated, or put down in order so that the Sociopathic tyrant could maintain power. My grandfather got a first hand lesson in the terror of a Sociopathic politician. Joseph Stalin put my grandfather into a Siberian gulag for the better part of the next two decades on the eve of WWII. My grandfather's crimes were two 1) he was Jewish and 2)he ran a successful corner store in a small Siberian village. These two things made my grandfather a threat and a target, and Stalin felt the need to eliminate him. My grandfather paid for Stalin's Sociopathy with nearly twenty years of his life.

Everyday, citizens everywhere pay the price for the deeds of Sociopathic politicians. We pay for it with higher taxes. We pay for it with a bureaucracy that looks out for the interests of power brokers rather than the public. We pay for it by having a government full of waste, and one that looks out for special interests rather than the interests of the public at large. We pay for it by having corruption swept under the rug and overlooked. Of course, in the most extreme, citizens pay for it with their loss of life, liberty, and pursuit of happiness. The Sociopathic politician is a cancer to any political system and unfortunately the nature of the beast breeds such an individual. As such, we, the voters, must always be aware of it and be able to identify all Sociopathic politicians. Such a combination has explosive possibilities.

Sunday, December 14, 2008

Some Perspective on Sociopathy, Rod Blagojevich and the Illinois Political Machine

Here is how Sociopathy is defined.

Antisocial personality disorder (APD) is a mental disorder. It is defined by the American Psychiatric Association's Diagnostic and Statistical Manual: "The essential feature for the diagnosis is a pervasive pattern of disregard for, and violation of, the rights of others that begins in childhood or early adolescence and continues into adulthood."[1] Deceit and manipulation are considered essential features of the disorder. Therefore, it is essential in making the diagnosis to collect material from sources other than the individual being diagnosed. Also, the individual must be age 18 or older as well as have a documented history of a conduct disorder before the age of 15.[1]People having antisocial personality disorder are sometimes referred to as "sociopaths" and "psychopaths", although some researchers believe that Psychopathy/Sociopathy are not synonymous with AsPD.[2]

Here is a review of the charges against Rod Blagojevich. First, he is suspected of attempting to sell the Senate seat vacated by Barack Obama for cash, favors, jobs for himself and his wife. He is charged with attempting to extort the Chicago Tribune. He wanted to remove those critical of him from their editorial board in exchange for funds the company needed to complete the sale of the Cubs and Wrigley Field. Furthermore, he was charged with withholding funds from a hospital unless its principle contributed to his campaign. He even attempted to broker a deal in which the SEIU would provide him with a cushy job in exchange for a favorable pick to the U.S. Senate. In other words, here is an individual that was entrusted with serving the public and he used this position for nothing more than personal gain. Never has there been a more clear example of a sociopath than this.

In the aftermath of these startling allegations, much of the media and political establishment in Chicago, Cook County, and Springfield have reacted with horror and shock. It is as though his behavior is peculiar and surprising. Is this really so? Here is how John Kass, the only Chicago area media person to write about the corruption here with unvarnished truth, put Blagojevich's actions into context.

But that same day, I diagnosed Blagojevich as quite sane, because all he did was act like just another corrupt Chicago politician. He squeezed people. That's how things are done in the city that is not Camelot.

Still, Illinois Atty. Gen. Lisa Madigan asked the state Supreme Court on Friday to declare Blagojevich "disabled." She called on the justices—some of whom are there by grace of the Chicago machine—to remove Blagojevich, pronto.

"State government is paralyzed by a governor who is incapable of governing," Madigan insisted. "We would look to the fact that the term 'disability' legally is very broad, that it is not simply isolated to a physical or mental disability."Incapable of what? Signing his name to bills? He can sign his name, to bills, or to a federal witness list, which would be much nicer. But they don't want that, or another week or two of Gov. Dead Meat leading the nightly news.

The fact is that what has shocked the city, county, state, nation and world is the brazen nature in which Blagojevich committed his corruption. The corruption itself is frankly an everyday part of doing business. Todd Stroger, current President of Cook County, recently raised the Cook County sales tax above 10%, the highest in the nation. At the same time, he cut the budget of Cook County Hospital, also called John Stroger Hospital (named for his father the previous President of Cook County), and according to the local CBS affiliate Stroger has put multiple of his friends on the County's payroll with cushy six figure jobs.

Meanwhile, Lisa Madigan, the current Attorney General of Illinois, has been all over the news lately. She has in the last couple days been fervent in her opposition to Blagojevich and demand for him to step aside. This is a rather peculiar position. That's because while Blagojevich has committed his crimes she has been silent and absent in her role as top prosecutor in the State. I'm sure the fact that she is on most Democrat's short list to be the nominee for the next Governor has nothing to do with her new found righteous indignation.

Then, there is the head corruptor himself, Richard M. Daley. He runs the city of Chicago much like his father Richard J. Daley did, like a political machine. So, we can be sure that business is conducted based on patronage, bribes, favors, and back scratching. The list of corruption tied to Daley includes the Hired Truck scandal, patronage involving his chief deputy Robert Sorich, and a scheme in which $100 million meant to go to affirmative action recipients went to his WHITE friends. The city of Chicago isn't run for the benefit of the people he was elected to serve but rather for the benefits of the friends of Richard M. Daley. The same goes for the way in which Todd Stroger runs Cook County, and Rod Blagojevich has run the state of Illinois.

In my estimation, there are only two politicians that are genuinely against corruption, Tony Peraica a Republican and Forrest Claypool, a Democrat. So, as we all react with shock and horror to the revelation that Rod Blagojevich is corrupt, let's keep things in perspective. I'm not saying that the entire political apparatus in Chicago, Cook Cook County, and Springfield is sociopathic. All I'm saying is that my default position is that they are and each politician will have to prove to me otherwise.

Saturday, December 13, 2008

The Madigans' Peculiar Political Ploy

From the minute Lisa Madigan, Illinois' Attorney General, inserted herself into the Blagojevich fiasco, I smelled something rotten in Denmark. Madigan has done scant little to fight corruption both in the Governor's office and in the state at large. She first stated, disingenuously in my opinion, that she was ready to indict the Governor if he didn't step down immediately. Right after this, she called on an obscure state statute to allow the State's Supreme Court to remove Blagojevich because he is "unfit for office". The problem is that 1) this statute has never been used and 2) this statute was meant for those Governors that were actually incapicated. Being a sociopath is not exactly what the statute was meant for. Yet, Madigan made full of the media spotlight to come out firmly that Blagojevich needs to be removed.

The ploy is even more peculiar once you understand the full family relationships. Her father, Michael Madigan, is the Speaker of the Illinois House. He has a long and contentious history with the current Governor, even though they are both Democrats. (like Madigan's daughter) In 2007, while Blagojevich was merely under the cloud of suspicion, Madigan admitted that he did some research into potential impeachment hearings of Blagojevich. Now, more than ever, would be the time for Madigan to bring impeachment hearings. As Speaker he is the one with the power. He has the mandate and the will of the people. So, why is Madigan waiting? First, it's important to understand that his daughter Lisa was on most people's short list for the Senator's job, and she would also be an early front runner for Blagojevich's current job.

By stepping aside, Madigan also allows Lisa to grab the spotlight and distance herself as much as possible from Blagojevich. Job one for any Democrat running in the next two years in Illinois will be to put as much distance from Blagojevich as possible. In other words, most Democrats will need to perform a sleight of hand on the voters. Madigan would be one of those. While Fitzgerald was investigating, indicting, prosecuting, and convicting all sorts of power broker around Blagojevich and with his sights set directly on the Governor himself, Madigan was conspicously absent in doing the same duty from her own position of power.

It's very likely this latest ploy is an attempt by Madigan, the younger, to create the appearance that she is very far away from Blagojevich. Meanwhile, Madigan, the older, is staying out of her way for the time being so she can grab the Blagojevich distancing spotlight. If all of this sounds cynical, welcome to standard operating procedure in Chicago, Cook County and Springfield politics. Lisa Madigan has spent the last four years ignoring the corruption of Illinois politicians while Patrick Fitzgerald has been a one man wrecking crew trying to bring down the entire system on his own. Now, she sees an opportunity to appear as a crusader against corruption and she is taking it. Hopefully, the voters won't be fooled, but my guess is this is exactly the sort of ploy that she will use to distance herself from Blagojevich when the time comes for her to make her next move up the ladder of Illinois power.

Sunday, November 23, 2008

Michael Vick's Very Troubling Profile

Earlier this week, Michael Vick was back in court to face a series of state charges.

Vick is serving a 23-month sentence in a minimum-security federal prison camp in Leavenworth, Kan., on a conspiracy charge relating to the interstate dogfighting operation he helped run on a property he owned in Surry County, Va. Vick is scheduled to be released on July 20, 2009.

Vick is currently being held in protective custody at Riverside Regional Jail in Hopewell, Va., until his hearing on Tuesday in Surry County Circuit Court to plead guilty to two state charges related to dogfighting.

The state charges -- one count of torturing and killing dogs and one count of promoting dogfighting -- each carry a maximum prison term of five years. But under the terms of his plea agreement, Vick is expected to receive a three-year suspended prison term and a $2,500 fine (which would be suspended if he pays court costs and maintains good behavior for four years).

By resolving the pending state charges, Vick would qualify to participate in the Federal Bureau of Prisons re-entry program, which could enable him to serve part of the
remainder of his federal sentence in a halfway house.


I for one hope that Vick gets his life back on track and I am willing to forgive him if he genuinely looks for forgiveness. That said, the nature of the crimes has admitted to along with his profile lead to a very troubling combination.

First, his participation in dog fighting has all the hallmarks of a sociopath, an individual devoid of a conscience. That's frankly the only way he could justify such a brutal act on a defenseless animal. He justified it because in his mind there was nothing to justify. A sociopath is so selfish that anyone else's feelings or thoughts never enter to the equation in their decision making process. Michael Vick justified being the ringleader in this dog fighting operation because the brutality that this would do to the dogs never even crossed his mind when he made the decision.

Second, to find the brutal sport of dog fighting enjoyable an individual must be afflicted with an enormous amount of sadism. Vick enjoys the sight of pain in a way that would make must people squirm. Rather than squirming, Vick gets a rush out of watching others inflict pain on each other.

Someone with this much sadistic tendencies is exposed to all sorts of criminal tendencies far beyond dog fighting, and when those tendencies are combined with sociopathy.
Finally, prior to being jailed, Michael Vick was in the middle of a contract worth well in excess of $100 million. This not only likely gives Vick an enormous sense of entitlement but power. It gives Vick the resources to do a nearly unlimited amount of damage but also the sense of entitlement for the worst kind of reckless behavior.
It's frankly not a very long road from animal torture to crimes much worse than that. In fact, serial killers like Jeffrey Dahmer started their evil with animal torture. The sort of behavior traits that it takes in order to engage in such a vicious behavior is exactly the sort of behavior that creates criminals and other sociopaths that spend their lives being a cancer to every situation they come into contact with. I hope that Michael Vick has taken his time in jail to try and conquer his demons, but if he hasn't, he has a very troubling profile. It's a profile of an individual that will go on to do things much worse than orchestrating a dog fighting ring.

Tuesday, July 15, 2008

Does Barack Obama Understand Evil II

This article from Ryan Lizza of the New Yorker is generating a lot of publicity from many in the conservative media. (H/T to Little Green Footballs) First, it is quite long. It is almost the size of a good short story though of course it is non fiction. The article focuses, in detail, on Obama's rise through Chicago politics. The article is so in depth that it allows folks to pick and choose that which they find most interesting. As a Chicagoan myself, I will commend Lizza on getting things in proper context of the cesspool that is our city's politics, and so I recommend reading it as long as you put about a half hour aside. (I wrote a much shorter article on this subject myself)

The article is rather unflattering. It paints Obama as the polar opposite of the "new kind of politician" that he has tried to cultivate. Besides the negative image painted, some in the conservative media have fixated on a quote dug up in the aftermath of 9/11 for an article for the local Hyde Park Herald. (Hyde Park being the neighborhood where Obama maintains his home as well as the area surrounding the University of Chicago)


Even as I hope for some measure of peace and comfort to the bereaved families, I must also hope that we as a nation draw some measure of wisdom from this tragedy. Certain immediate lessons are clear, and we must act upon those lessons decisively. We need to step up security at our airports. We must reexamine the effectiveness of our intelligence networks. And we must be resolute in identifying the perpetrators of these heinous acts and dismantling their organizations of destruction.

We must also engage, however, in the more difficult task of understanding the sources of such madness. The essence of this tragedy, it seems to me, derives from a fundamental absence of empathy on the part of the attackers: an inability to imagine, or connect with, the humanity and suffering of others. Such a failure of empathy, such numbness to the pain of a child or the desperation of a parent, is not innate; nor, history tells us, is it unique to a particular culture, religion, or ethnicity. It may find expression in a particular brand of violence, and may be channeled by particular demagogues or fanatics. Most often, though, it grows out of a climate of poverty and
ignorance, helplessness and despair.

We will have to make sure, despite our rage, that any U.S. military action takes into account the lives of innocent civilians abroad. We will have to be unwavering in opposing bigotry or discrimination directed against neighbors and friends of Middle Eastern descent. Finally, we will have to devote far more attention to the monumental task of raising the hopes and prospects of embittered children across the globe—children not just in the Middle East, but also in Africa, Asia, Latin America, Eastern Europe and within our own shores.

Generally, I think that most are making the proverbial mountain of a molehill out of this, however, there is one very troubling aspect to this quote to me. Recently, I wrote a piece entitled Does Barack Obama Understand Evil? Obama does a lot of equivocating between ourselves and our enemies, in my opinion, and it makes me wonder if he understands evil. Some of the things found in this piece make me wonder some more.

First, it is the understatement of the millenia to say that the terrorists lacked empathy. Of course, they lacked empathy. In psychology, we have term for someone who lacks empathy, a sociopath. Sociopaths are of course by nature evil.

What should be bothersome is that Obama attributes their sociopathy to

It may find expression in a particular brand of violence, and may be channeled by particular demagogues or fanatics. Most often, though, it grows out of a climate of poverty and ignorance, helplessness and despair.

Of course, this is nonsense. Sociopathy is derived from extreme selfishness, to the point that no one matters but yourself. As such, sociopaths lose all sense of empathy. Sociopaths span the cross section of social, economic, and racial classes. To attribute the terrorist's lack of empathy to poverty and ignorance totally misconstrues their evil.

These folks are guided by the laser light belief in their twisted ideology. Their ideology demands that others die. As such, the lives of others are totally inconsequential in their minds. If folks need to die in order to achieve their ends so be it. That is the nature of their evil.

Of course, it has been pointed out ad nauseum that many of the terrorists were themselves middle class. UBL was of course fabulously wealthy. Poverty had absolutely nothing to do with their evil. For Obama to attribute their evil to some sort of lack of economic achievement totally misconstrues it. If Barack Obama doesn't understand evil he is totally unprepared to face the villains all over the next President will have to deal with. Clearly, based on this particular piece, one has to wonder if Barack Obama understands evil.

Monday, February 18, 2008

Deciphering Brzezinski's Trip to Syria

Zbigniew Brzezinski, top foreign policy advisor to Barack Obama, recently made a low key trip to Syria to meet with its leader, Bashar Assad.

What in the world are advisers to both Senators Obama and Clinton doing in Syria in the middle of a presidential campaign — and why are the two campaigns so unforthcoming about the details of the visits? The same week that a terrorist mastermind harbored by the Baathist regime in Damascus was assassinated by a car bomb, both one of Mr. Obama's foreign policy counselors, Zbigniew Brzezinski, a long-time critic of Israel, and one of Mrs. Clinton's national finance chairs, Hassan Nemazee, were meeting with President Assad.

The article, along with much of the media all over, is speculating over what Brzezinski was doing there. That is a fascinating question, however we should start by looking at exactly who Brzezinski is. Brezizinski is a leading foreign policy thinker from the school of the realists. The realists see our aggressive action in the GWOT as largely imperialistic, and they don't believe that we can force change upon the Middle East. They certainly don't see change taking place through force, and rather they see the U.S. working with the governments currently ruling and affecting change through non violent means.

While few oppose the goal of political and economic liberalization, many individuals question both the morality and the efficacy of using military force and diplomatic pressure to achieve these aims. This was the starting point for our discussion, and continues to be the organizing principle (Statement of Principles) on which we operate.

In order to counter the arguments of those who favor empire, the Coalition holds conferences, and media events, promotes research, and communicates a vision of the alternatives to American empire, including a restrained foreign policy that protects American interests.


Thus, the short answer for why Brzezinski is meeting with Assad is that he is a leading realist thinker. A better question is will this be effective. There is an old unattributed saying that describes my feelings about meeting with the enemy...

you negotiate with the enemy with your knee in his chest and your knife at his throat

Obama clearly believes you negotiate with your enemy by trying to charm them. On one level, I can see how he believes this and that's because he has spent much of his life being able to charm most everyone he meets. Why should the leaders of countries such as Iran, Syria, and North Korea be any different? The problem for me with this thinking is that unlike most people the leaders of these nations are sociopaths. For them, every meeting, every word, and every action is set in the context of achieving their own agenda.

First instance, we don't know what the meeting was about but let's say that Brzezinski assured Assad that once Obama was in office that our policy would be less aggressive toward him. Assad would immediately take such a sign as he should lay low, not cause trouble, and wait out Bush's Presidency until a new admin takes over that he can much more easily manipulate. Assad is not interested in peace. He is interested in consolidating and expanding his power. He is likely involved in the death's of several Lebanese politicians, training and infiltration of terrorists into Iraq, and he may even have been behind the death of Hezbollah terrorist Imad Mugniyeh. (not to mention having Damascus as the location for the main office of such terrorist groups as Hezbollah as well as all sorts of bellicose language toward Israel) Assad is no partner for peace and peace is frankly not on his agenda. No amount of sweet talk is going to change him in my opinion.

Yet, that is essentially what Obama and Brezizinski plan on turning the GWOT and U.S. foreign policy in general into. What an Obama Presidency will look like on foreign policy matters is shuttle diplomacy among our many enemies. It is quite ironic that Obama suggested that if need be he would infiltrated Pakistan without the permission of Musharraf because he gives a tyrant like Assad and Ahmadinejad more consideration than an admittedly flawed ally like Musharraf. He has already stated he wants unconditional negotiations with Iran in his first year as President. Now, his top foreign policy advisor is meeting with Assad. One can only imagine what sort of plan he has for North Korea.

The Middle East is a messy and sticky place. Even our allies are duplicitous at best. Deciding who to trust is difficult because ultimately you really can't trust anyone. A foreign policy predicated on the philosophy that we will work with all seems naive and downright dangerous to me, and yet that is exactly what Obama has embraced by employing Brzezinski. Among the many debates that I hope we have this election cycle is the one about the wisdom of realist foreign policy which frankly makes no distinction between friend and foe.

Wednesday, January 9, 2008

Deconstructing Barack Obama

This piece would have been a lot more timely yesterday at about four P.M. Central time when every person of note was predicting an Obama ten point victory and clear sailing to the nomination. Still, his campaign is formidable and should not be underestimated. He has three things that make any candidate formidable in any free election: charm, charisma and likeability. That said, I believe a combination of incompetence and little substantive difference has stopped Hillary from stripping Obama's message down and exposing it for the house of cards that it is. He is running on a very powerful message... a message of hope and unity. From my perspective that message is built on nothing. Obama doesn't say anything any other politician wouldn't say, he just says it in a charismatic way so that folks believe him. The problem for Hillary is that her policies aren't substantively any different than his. Thus, she can't attack his policies and thus his message gets out to the public.





The Republican candidate should have no such trouble, and so here is how I believe his opponent should deconstruct Obama and strip him of his hopeful message.






The first issue is illegal immigration. I pointed out earlier that in words and deeds Obama has a steadfast record of open borders policy that shows more compassion for law breakers than for the rule of law. In last summer's illegal immigration debate, he voted against two amendments of note: one to outlaw criminals and terrorists from entering the country and the other to commit to following the laws already on the books. When Obama was in the Illinois legislature, he was one of the legislators leading the charge to grant driver's licenses to illegals in the state. Driver's licenses for illegals was rejected by seventy percent of liberal New York staters. That gives you an idea of how it would play in the rest of the country.






Here is what Obama said to the open borders group La Raza...









And I will never walk away from the 12 million undocumented immigrants who live, work, and contribute to our country every single day.



He has absolutely no plan for securing the borders. He skipped a vote to outlaw sanctuary cities like his hometown, Chicago, and voted to allow children of illegals amnesty through the DREAM Act. These maybe positions that are favored by the Democratic base but are totally untennable in any general election. The Republican candidates all have tough border enforcement credentials, yes even John McCain, and they can and better attack his open borders policy.






His social policy can be summed up this way...he stands to the left of Planned Parenthood on abortion. He once voted for a bill that actually allows doctors to still abort a baby even after it is out of the womb. The bill was called the Born Alive Infant Protection Act and here is how Amanda Carpenter described his actions on this bill...









But Obama voted against this bill in the Illinois senate and killed it in committee. Twice, the Induced Infant Liability Act came up in the Judiciary Committee on which he served. At its first reading he voted “present.” At the second he voted “no.”



Let's remember Obama is not merely pro abortion but he goes so far as to be pro partial birth abortion. The Supreme Court decision on partial birth abortion became an issue in the Democratic Primary this past spring. Here is how Obama reacted...






I am extremely concerned that this ruling will embolden state legislatures to enact further measures to restrict a woman's right to choose, and that the conservative Supreme Court justices will look for other opportunities to erode Roe v. Wade, which is established federal law and a matter of equal rights for women,






Now, any veterans of my work know that I have a serious problem with emotional rather than logical arguements. That said, his support of partial birth abortion presents a great opportunity for any Republican (Rudy included who is against partial birth abortion) to run an advertisement appealing to emotion. Most people have no idea how brutal the act of partial birth abortion is. Any add that describes its brutality and links Obama to it can easily appeal to folk's emotions.
Here is how the process is described.
The entire infant is delivered except the head. A scissors isjammed into the base of the skull. A tube is inserted into the skull, and the brain is sucked out. The now-dead infant is pulled out.
Now, that makes for a visual advertisement. The brutality and inhumanity of partial birth abortion is unspeakable and Obama is not only on record as supporting the process but condemning a Supreme Court decision as some sort of a slippery slope intrusion on reproductive rights. Clearly, Obama will look to appoint judges that see this practice as perfectly constitutional and that is something for his opponent to exploit. Again, while partial birth abortion may play in the Dem primary it won't in the general election.
On Iraq and the GWOT he also has issues to exploit. His position is on Iraq becomes less and less tennable each day. He will have to BS his way through the position. The surge continues to show more and more signs of progress and we are still eleven months from the election. Keep in mind that Obama favors a withdrawal of forces. That withdrawal would reverse every single gain the surge has produced and snatch defeat from the jaws of victory. A vote for Obama means a victory in Iraq for Al Qaeda. It is as simple as that and the Rep opponent must hammer that home. On the GWOT in general, his position is convoluted and naive. He favors dialogue with sociopathic dictators like Ahmadinejad and Assad. He has even hinted at an opening of dialogue with Castro in Cuba. Obama foolishly believes that he can charm the despots and dictators of this world.
The key to countering his naive message and exposing it for what it is..is credibility. John McCain has the most credibility on the war in the Rep field. Most of the candidates have some credibility, however McCain would be in the best position to expose it. Keep in mind that Obama insinuates that his plan for dialogue is new. It isn't. The Clinton admin met many times with both Assad and Arafat. It didn't work, and dialogue with sociopaths never works. The only way dialogue would work is when those despots are in a clear position of weakness. Reagan first created an arms race the Soviets couldn't win and only after the Soviets knew it did he dialogue. Obama's dialogue is described by himself as unconditional and that position can be exposed for the naive and inexperienced that it is.
On the economy, attacking Obama is a lot more difficult. The economy will likely be in trouble and many of his domestic programs, like universal health care, poll well. That said, I would attack them two ways. The first is with my favorite Reagan quote
The nine most terrifying words in the English language are 'I'm from the government and I'm here to help'"
Obama thinks our health care system is broken and he wants to help. He thinks our mortgage system is broken and he wants the government to help. He, like most traditional liberals, thinks the government must ultimately control the economy. I personally would merely like one of the Republicans to invoke the phrase in response to anyone of his numerous big government, ultimately more taxes, proposals, however the concept is there no matter how it is described.
Second, the Reps must make it known that this election comes down to those that believe the government knows best and th market knows best. I pointed out yesterday that embryonic stem cell research is one of many examples of liberals believing that the government is a better arbitor than the free market. Obama is like any other standard liberal who believes that on issue after issue: health care, global warming, mortgages, embryonic stem cell research, it is the job of the government to make decisions and not the free market. I disagree and I firmly believe that any candidate that wants to put all this control in the hands of the government is a candidate that will lose.
Finally, there is experience. The reason that this hasn't worked for Hillary isn't only because the Democratic electorate is looking for a message of hope and change, it is also because her so called experience is a fraud. The major Rep candidates have no such problem. Whether it is Mike Huckabee, Rudy Giuliani, John McCain, or Mitt Romney, all of these candidates have real, practical experience and a history of effectiveness and leadership. Obama has nothing. The biggest thing he has run is his Senate office. Obama has a standard response that involves saying that experience could be the wrong kind of experience. That is true with Hillary because she really had no experience. Rudy turned around a city deemed ungovernable, and lead them through crisis and turmoil. Is that the wrong kind of experience? Huckabee governed his state for ten plus years and left as one of the most popular and successful in his state. Is that the wrong kind of experience? Romney ran a successful business, olympics and then a state...is that the wrong kind? John McCain is a war hero, Senate leader and a main of unquestioned principle, toughness and moral being. Is that the wrong kind of experience? Barack Obama's inexperience only appears to be a non issue because he is matched up with folks who's experience is really no different than his. In the general election, that will no longer be the case.

Saturday, January 5, 2008

The CMU Student Code of Conduct and Absolute Power

Prologue: Just like the fiasco at Emory University, Grady Hospital and beyond, this fiasco at Central Michigan University also has many twists and turns. The website The Peters Report has published a two part summary of the events. Please note that this site is run by a group called Students against Gary Peters. While I believe that the events are described accurately and fairly, it would also be fair to describe the site as having an agenda.

Introduction:
There is an appropriate saying:
absolute power corrupts absolutely.
The manner in which the administration has tried to deal with their student, Dennis Lennox, is in my opinion a great example of this saying in action.

From the beginning the thing that has bothered me most about this case is that Lennox is the only individual that I have found that acted in the spirit of what college is supposed to be. He challenged authority. He got involved and he became an activist. He was innovative and bold. Isn't that what we want all our college students to be like? Rather than engage his activism, it appears that CMU eventually viewed it as a threat. They then moved immediately to in a heavy handed manner eliminate that threat. Furthermore, the administration not only liberally used their powers under the student code of conduct, but furthermore relied on several vague, likely unconstitutional, certainly unfair, rules and regulations to try and eliminate him.

When you cut through the fog, CMU is in the process of sanctioning Lennox with a possible punishment of expulsion for: bringing a video camera to a public place, distributing literature too close to a public meeting, and not identifying himself properly. Frankly, they have taken every ideal our founding fathers struggled so mightily to give us and twisted them beyond all recognition.

What scares me most is that while the CMU administration is an entity and not an individual, they exhibit classic and textbook behavior of a sociopath. As I will attempt to show, eventually, in the perspective of the administration, Lennox went from a nuisance to a threat. Once he became a threat the administration did everything they could think of, no matter how ridiculous or unconstitutional, to eliminate him. They sanctioned him and even are in the process of attempting to expel him. That, frankly, is textbook and classic sociopathic behavior.

Now, let's start at the beginning. For a while, CMU didn't necessarily take Dennis Lennox as anything more than an annoyance and maybe even a fascination. That all changed with this confrontation with Dean of Student affairs Pamela Gates. Subsequent to this confrontation, the behavior of CMU administration toward Lennox became quite heavy handed.

Lennox was subsequently cited on numerous charges that I would call dubious: distributing fliers too close to a public forum, bringing a video camera to a public place, and not identifying himself properly to a university official. Here is how the university explained the initial charge.



You have been cited for violating sections 3.2.2 (Providing false information to a university official); 3.2.15 (Not identifying yourself to a university agent when asked) and 3.2.32 (Distributing printed materials in violation of the Advocacy Policy) of the CMU Code of Student Rights, Responsibilities and Disciplinary Procedures during an incident that occurred in Anspach Hall on October 23, 2007.

Now, here is code 3.2.2 of their student code of conduct



A student shall not furnish, or attempt to furnish, false or misleading information to University officials or on official University records. Furthermore, he/she shall not forge, alter, or misuse the University name, the name of any University employee, documents, records of identification, or attempt to do the same.

Here is 3.2.15



A student shall comply with the directions of University agents acting in the performance of their regular or delegated duties and must identify him self or her self to these agents upon request.

All of this relates to one incident in which Lennox was cited by a university official for passing out literature in a manner that violated their policy. Their policy forbids distribution of literature any closer than 25 feet from any doorway. When he was confronted by the official, Lennox refused to identify himself violating another policy. First, the very policy that forbids distribution of literature any closer than 25 feet from a door is in and of itself likely unconstitutional and certainly against the entire spirit of the first amendment.

Second the University both claims that Lennox misrepresented himself and that he didn't identify himself at all. Obviously he couldn't have simultaneously not identified himself at all and also misrepresented himself, so the administration has a convoluted arguement here.

Now, the way the story has been told to me is that in fact Lennox did refuse to identify himself when asked, and it would be fair to describe Lennox' behavior as confrontational, condescending and even arrogant. Lennox himself, vehemently, believes this is an unfair and inaccurate description of the way in which the events unfolded. His behavior during the incident is a side issue. Even if he likely acted like a jerk, completely out of character for a college student (?), is this really the sort of thing that university officials need to file formal procedural charges for? Wouldn't it have made more sense if the official Lennox had confronted had merely given him a stiff talking to and ended the matter there?

The citation against video cameras is even more dubious. The university doesn't have any such regulation against video cameras. Rather they have this all encompassing regulation.



Violation of other university regulations, policies or established procedures may be treated as an offense under these regulations.

The way this portion of the student code was explained to me is that the University has an all encompassing power to create rules as they see fit. We all remember the famous line in Animal House.



They are? Well, as of this moment, they're on DOUBLE SECRET PROBATION!

Well, the fictional dean was using a similar fictional code. In the movie, he also had sweeping powers to regulate the school as he saw fit. While that was of course entirely set up for comedic purposes, the manner in which CMU used their own power is not at all funny.

CMU essentially mandated that video cameras would no longer be allowed in their public areas. They sent Lennox a letter with this mandate and uder the student code, all students must follow all directives handed down from the administration. If I understand their student code correctly, the administration could literally force a student to be home by a certain hour if they pleased. That is the sort of sweeping powers they left themselves within their code of conduct. What is unclear is whether or not this directive applied to all students or merely Lennox. It is, however clear, that it was only enforced toward one student.

This directive was so absurd that even the ACLU felt the need to act.



...letter from the American Civil Liberties Union addressed to Central Michigan University President Michael Rao and dated November 27th requesting that the University lift a ban on videotaping Professor Gary Peters on campus, a ban targeted at a conservative student, Dennis Lennox. According to the ACLU the University's decision "violates Mr. Lennox's First Amendment right to engage in political advocacy."

The administration has been wishy washy as to whether or not the ban on cameras applied to all students or just Lennox. It is clear it was only enforce on Lennox. Not only is banning cameras a violation of the first amendment, but when that ban is only enforced on one student, that violates the fourteenth amendment. Again, who is being held responsible for this gross abuse of power?

As convoluted, vague, and unfair as the charges are, that is only the beginning of the story. The manner in which the administration carries out the investigation, trial and punishment is no less fair. In a trial, you receive copies of every piece of evidence the other side is holding. Not so in the case of the CMU code of conduct (here is an email to Lennox explaining)



You have the right under FERPA to inspect your file, but not to have
copies of the information included within the file.

Furthermore, the hearings are closed due to what I consider dubious right to privacy reasons. Finally, the entire structure is open to corruption. After all, the deciding panel is made up nearly entirely of administration officials. In this case, and likely in most cases, it is administration officials that are levvying the charges. In that climate, does it seem likely a student would get a fair shake?

Beyond this the same school officials that are ready to throw the book at Lennox for what to me amounts to nothing more than exercising his first amendment rights, never hold themselves responsible. Dean Pamela Gates is now on record as admitting that she "lost it" when she was confronted with the video camera in the incident I linked to earlier.



First, Dean Pamela Gates admitted to other university officials in the moments after the videotaping-assault incident that she "lost it". OutsideLansing.com agrees with her conclusion.

This admission by the Dean, when she contacted her bosses immediately after the incident, suggests that she understood the nature of her reaction as an overreaction. It is about the only thing of interest in the summary of the incident between"Student C" (we can not verify for sure that this was Dennis Lennox, however, it stands to reason) and Ms. Gates (that a PDF of 325KB size from Zarko Research & Consulting). The only other thing of minor interest is that Student C's voice was "loud, demanding, and directive" - there is no evidence or even discussion of an assault by Student C on anyone in the office, or of anything other than Student C saying "Thank you" in an allegedly "sarcastic and condescending" way. The best reason CMU can give for its official's behavior is it didn't like the "tone" of what Student C was saying - hardly justification for what is becoming a witch-hunt now against this student.

Lennox is being held accountable for distributing literature too close to a door however the dean of students is not being held accountable for "losing it" when confronted by a STUDENT.

Beyond that, the administration poisoned the perverbial waters when they Lennox as such in a series of emails


Mr. Lennox is not only someone with noxious political and social beliefs, but someone who has mental health issues, and someone who seems to be losing control. The psychologist's advice (he has been following some of this on the news) is the following: "Don't provoke him. Don't initiate a confrontation of any sort, be it email, letter, or a face-to-face. He will respond in kind and escalate. Do not respond to correspondence, taunts, or 'stalking behavior' other than by calling the police. Appoint a mediator, if possible, from the counseling center [a neutral party], to try to convince him to either get help, back off or face scholastic or legal consequences." The psychologist went on to say that he thought that Lennox was a ticking bomb of sorts: he's angry [a little ball of hate, really], he's been rejected by other conservatives, and he has fixated on certain groups of people as the ultimate cause of his unhappiness. I know we are all furious with Lennox, and despise what he represents—let's face it, a movement that loathes academe and all it stands for. But I do think the above advice is solid and worth considering. Oh, and Horowitz has had connections with the Christian Right and the YAF because of their shared hatred for Muslims. It's a weird partnership, but one that has been flourishing for at least 10 years (Frontline did something on it a few years ago).

and this incendiary response...


So are you saying that this kid is dangerous? As in Virginia Tech dangerous? Let's not ignore the warning signs...

(First, I will point out that the characterization of Lennox by an administration that has made him their adversary is not coincidentally quite similar to the manner in which the Emory University administration characterized whistleblower Kevin Kuritzky). The folks that exchanged these emails have such letters as PH.D following their names. Is it really appropriate for them to characterize Lennox' activism as some sort of a mental healh problem. A psychologist is alluded to and this shrink apparently gives mental advice without actually treating Lennox. Furthermore, the initial email specifically says that Lennox shouldn't be provoked and yet the admin did exactly that subsequently. Not only did they provoke him but they are threatening him with expulsion. If they really believe their characterization, is this really the proper course? Furthermore, the initial email tries to trade on their prior experience...


I used to work in mental health, and quite frankly the pattern of behavior we've been witnessing is disturbing and indicates that Mr. Lennox is not only someone with noxious political and social beliefs, but someone who has mental health issues

Nowhere in the rest of the email does the author explain how they came to such a conclusion. They merely sling mud against groups and individuals that Lennox belongs to and trade off on the opinion of an unidentified psychologist who never even treated Lennox. (Frankly, I assume that no one is treating Lennox because he likely has no mental health issues that are in any way different from that of any other college student).

Finally, there is this. Let's look at the section in the school code of conduct relating to drinking.

A student shall not possess, use, manufacture, produce, or distribute, or aid in the use, manufacture, production, or distribution of, any controlled substance except as expressly permitted by law and university policy. Violation of the Residence Life Alcohol and Controlled Substances Policy is a violation of this section. Controlled substances are defined in the Controlled Substances Act of 1971, as amended.

3.2.13 Violation of Alcohol Policy. A student shall not possess, consume or furnish, or aid in the consumption or furnishing of, alcoholic beverages except as permitted by law and University policy. Violation of the Residence Life Alcohol & Controlled Substances Policy is a violation of this section.

Now, if Central Michigan University is like any other campus in the nation, how many of its student body violated this provision while CMU strenuously enforced a provision that prohibited distributing literature within 25 feet of a door? How many students drank while technically underage with no punishment from the university while it pursued Lennox to the maximum of the rules for distributing literature?

Finally, I pointed out that emails show that the political science department has beome poisoned and overly ideological. In fact, the words of the very person in charge, Del Lingquist, damn the department he runs. Yet, he hasn't been reprimanded or held accountable either.

Earlier, I pointed out that this behavior has all the hallmarks of a sociopath. I want to be careful here or I will do exactly what I accuse the admin of doing and poison the waters against them unfairly while accusing them of the same. I didn't come to this decision lightly, however as my favorite Latin phrase goes, Res Ipsa Loquitor (the facts speak for themselves)

The only one being held accountable now is Lennox himself. Despite a pattern of behavior in which administration officials show arrogance, heavy handedness, and other abuses of power, that behavior is not examined or punished. The only behavior that is currently being scrutinized is the handing out of literature too close to a door, a video camera on public property, and a student arrogantly refusing to identify themself. There is nothing consistent or fair about the process or anything in it. The only conclusion I can draw from this set of facts is that the administration has a goal, hiring and keeping Gary Peters, and Lennox stands in the way of that goal and thus they are doing everything to eliminate him. That is the hallmarks of sociopathic behavior.